Field of Science

Screening probes and probing screens

ResearchBlogging.orgHigh Throughput Screening (HTS), with all its strengths and limitations, is still the single-best way to discover novel interesting molecules in drug discovery. Thomas Kodadek of Scripps Florida has an interesting article on screening in the latest issue of Nat. Chem. Biol which is a special issue on chemical probes.

Kodadek talks about the very different properties required for drugs and probes and the limitations and unmet needs in current HTS strategies. He focuses on mainly two kinds of screening; functional assays and binding assays. The former can consist of phenotypic screening wherein one is only interested in a particular cellular response. This is more useful for drugs. However for probes, target selectivity is important and one must have knowledge of the target. HTS hits can hit all kinds of protein targets, thus making it hard to find out if your compounds are being selective. Mutagenesis and siRNA studies can shed light on target selectivity but this is not easy to do.

One of the possible solutions Kodadek suggests to circumvent the problem of gauging selectivity is to use binding assays instead of functional assays. He notes a pretty clever idea used in binding assays; that of throwing in cell extracts with miscellaneous proteins that could mop up greasy, non-selective compounds. This strategy cannot be easily used in functional assays. Binding assays are also typically less expensive than functional assays.

There is also a discussion of some of the very practical problems associated with screening. Screening typically has low hit rates and more importantly, hits from screening are not leads. You usually need a dedicated team of synthetic chemists to make systematic SAR modifications to these hits to optimize them further. As the author says, few synthetic chemists wish to serve as SAR facilities for their biologist colleagues. Plus it is not easy to lure industrial chemists to serve this function in academia (although the present economic climate may have made this easier). Thus, biologists with no synthetic background need to be able to make at least some modifications to their hits. For this purpose Kodadek suggests the use of modular molecules with easily available building blocks which can be cheaply and easily connected together by relatively inexperienced chemists; foremost in his recommendations are peptoids, N-substituted oligoglycines which are biologically active and easy to synthesize. Thus, if libraries for screening are enriched in such kinds of molecules, it could make it easy for biologists without access to sophisticated synthetic chemists and facilities to cobble together leads. Of course this would lead to a loss of diversity in the libraries, but that's the tradeoff necessary for going down the long road from hit to lead.

Lastly, Kodadek briefly talks about prospects for screening in academia. Academic drug discovery is gradually becoming more attractive with the recent long lull in industry. However academic scientists are typically not very familir with the post-synthesis optimization of drugs including optimization of metabolic properties, bioavailability and PK. Academic scientists who can pursue such studies or partner with DMPK contracting companies may be paid back their dues.

One topic which Kodadek does not mention is virtual screening (VS). VS can complement HTS and at least some studies indicate that the rate of success in VS can match, if not exceed, that in HTS. In addition, new ligand-based methods which use properties such as molecular shape to screen for compounds similar to given hits can also valuably complement HTS follow up studies.

Screening is still the best bet for discovering new drugs, but hit rates are typically still very low (1% would be a godsend). Only a concerted effort at designing libraries, ensuring selectivity and synthetic accessibility will make it easier.

Kodadek, T. (2010). Rethinking screening Nature Chemical Biology, 6 (3), 162-165 DOI: 10.1038/nchembio.303

Middle Ages March

As far as possible I try to avoid writing about the teaching of evolution and opposition to climate change in this country because of their overly politicized nature, but this piece in the NYT is one that no one can wisely ignore. It details a growing movement to conflate rejection of evolution with rejection of climate change that many people, and sadly especially conservatives, are spearheading. States are trying to introduce bills encouraging the teaching of “all sides” of scientific issues. Conservative politicians are advocating for students to know “all the facts”. But nobody is fooled by these thinly veiled promotions of ignorance. These developments should appear ominous to anyone since they indicate a resourceful war against science and all it stands for.

A couple of years ago, journalist Chris Mooney wrote "The Republican War on Science", a laundry list of instances of systematic negligence and subversion by the Bush administration when it came to scientific matters. When Obama became President, those of us like Mooney heaved a sigh of relief, since the new President seemed to have a genuine appreciation for science and its funding and strove to "restore science to its rightful place". Sadly, what we did not fully realize is that the War on Science is not really fought in the corridors of Washington but rather on the streets and churches of states all over the country. No Presidential mandate can quell the intensity with which the foot soldiers in these quarters fight the war.

The main goal of these foot soldiers is to seed doubts about the foundational nature of scientific facts in the minds of the gullible. They want to misrepresent the tentative nature of scientific understanding as equivalent to complete lack of understanding. They don't understand or willfully neglect the simple fact that some things in science are more certain than others, and many things are so well-understood so as to be virtually certain. But by pitching the very nature of science as some kind of loose, tentative theorizing disguised as facts, these eager evangelists are destroying the very fabric of scientific inquiry and indeed, one of the essential bedrocks on which modern civilization is founded. To me their ultimate objective seems clear; convince people that most if not all of science and not just climate change and evolution consists of "just theories". Once that basic groundwork has been established, they are free to play fast and loose with each and every aspect of science that bears on public policy, which in the modern world encompasses most important spheres of political and public activity.

The anti-science crowd is too clever to call for downright subversion of science and embrace of religious dogma. Consider Tim Moore, a politician from Kentucky who claims that his motivation is not religious but it is to oppose the “distortion of scientific knowledge”. Surely Moore is intelligent enough to understand the number of religious votes he would garner if his suggestions are implemented. Moore and others are too clever to directly call for an indictment of science. Hence they are resorting to the gradual mobilization of doubt. Start with eager young minds first. The relentless movement to include "intelligent" design in textbooks as a valid "alternative" to evolution is well-known. Now they are also calling for textbooks to teach "both sides" of climate change. The time will come when they would insist that every scientific topic with which they have an issue should be accompanied by its opposite in school textbooks, simply because scientists are engaging in healthy debate about that topic. Stem cells and alternative energy are two prominent issues that come to mind. Scientists are still not sure what kind of technologies would make solar and wind power a reality? Good! Make sure you include every bit of opposition to these technologies as part of your textbook lessons. Scientists are still trying to understand how exactly stem cells would make it possible to cure or contain life-threatening disorders? Fantastic! Make that a case for including every bit of opposition to stem cell research so that you could argue against it; the religious aspects could always be smuggled in later through the back door. Lively technical disagreements taking place in the pages of scientific journals would be held up as resounding evidence that the soul of science itself is an amorphous blob devoid of certain existence. This is nothing less than the rape and rabid hijacking of the normal scientific process to portray it as some kind of fundamental structural flaw in the whole enterprise.

If this kind of descent into ignorance is terrible for schools and students, it's not at all helped by declining standards of science and math education in this country and by global competition in science and technology. What may be even more tragic is that such efforts, which started during the Reagan era but were much milder back then, would form such an ungodly and impenetrable meld of science, conservative politics and religion that it may well become impossible to ever separate the three. Sadly, one consistently finds mainly Republicans being opposed to climate change and the teaching of evolution. Those few Republicans who do support either or both of these are already keeping their mouths shut for fear of being alienated from the party. At the same time, evangelical Christians are convincing their brothers and sisters to add climate change to their list of enemies which long includes evolution. Since the Reagan era conservatism has already become synonymous with evangelical religion. Now they are also trying to make the two synonymous with anti-scientism. The effect of all this would be to downright intimidate any person with conservative sentiments who dares to have respect for the scientific process. It would also mean an exponential decline in members of the conservative coalition with any appreciation of science; after all, if evolution and climate change deniers are going to be the main recruits to the movement, the probability that these people will have any appreciation for the scientific method would already be very low to begin with.

Accompanying this active propaganda against science is a slick publicity campaign that pits scientific issues as not really being scientific but being political dogfights between liberals and conservatives, and declares science and especially academic science to be a political liberal enterprise. It extols the folksy, down to earth demeanor of grass roots politicians and encourages derision towards "elitist", high-brow scientists educated at respectable schools along with the politicians of the Eastern Establishment who nurture them. The two-time election of George W Bush (ironically a failed member of the Eastern Establishment) demonstrated that many citizens of this country are indeed suckers for such stereotypes and are ready to fundamentally mistrust any educated intellectual or scientist. Whether we like it or not, conservatives have turned this confluence of mutually reinforcing strategies and stereotypes into a well-oiled PR machine that is set to pay its own way into hell.

Is there any silver lining at all to this precipitous slide into the Middle Ages? The article does talk about conservative Christians who seem to display a refreshing acceptance of both evolution and climate change. Their numbers are low, but their convictions seem strong. They think that earth and everything that it encompasses are God's creations and need to be taken care of. Atheists may vehemently disagree with this interpretation, but as E O Wilson says in his book ”Creation”, at least they can leave aside differences and try to find common ground for this most important of causes. No matter how powerful and influential the leaders of the war against science seem, they critically depend on the citizenry to make their voice known. They speak because their constituencies listen. They prey and thrive on the nods of their audience. Educate the audience, and the tables turn; now it’s they who decide whether the magician on stage lives or dies.

We don't know yet whether this citizenry can wake up to the wisdom of recognizing science as a value-neutral, apolitical, open-minded, independent and freedom-loving framework to improve their lives. But it is clear that to have any chance of rescuing this country from the divisive forces of ignorance which are gradually making their way from coast to coast, one must use every tactic at his or her disposal to drive home the importance of science and to try to reinforce its separation from politics and religion.

These days one regularly comes across opposite and polarized factions of "New Atheists" who are up in arms against "Accommodationists". The former faction believes that only a highly vocal effort to weed out religion from the masses can turn enough people toward science, even if it permanently alienates the hardest of the fundamentalists. The latter faction believes that a more moderate approach will work better. Both factions believe that fundamentalists will largely remain unmoved.

To me the arguments between them mainly seem to be based on degree, since many from the latter also call themselves atheists. I have never understood why the approach needs to be either/or. It is clear that insiders from the religious establishment still stand the best chance of convincing their own flock. These promising young insiders are going to be persuaded only when they are repeatedly convinced and in turn convince others that yes, they can safely practice their faith and still believe in science as a candle in the dark. Whether atheists like it or not, their support is crucial. People come in all kinds of shades, and the best bet for us to convince them about the value of science is to pitch it to them at all levels, in all forms and guises, vocally and mildly, through every possible channel. Human society is a complex organism, and it needs a complex mix of ideas to cause fundamental changes. Just like in my field of computational chemistry, when you don't know the composition of this mix, you simply try out all combinations.

It seems to be the least we can do to stop a straight downhill crash into dark ignorant oblivion.

A promising book falls apart

The atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki were such horrific and singular historical events that any new retelling of them deserves to be read seriously. It was with such thoughts that I picked up Charles Pellegrino's "The Last Train From Hiroshima". The first few pages were enough to glue me to my chair. In an almost poetically clinical manner Mr. Pellegrino describes the effects of the bomb on human beings in the first few seconds after the detonation. His accounts of people evaporating and the "iron in their blood separating" while their friends who were protected in "shock bubbles" that were mere feet away were absolutely riveting.

Yet in spite of this promising start I could not shake off the gnawing feeling that something was wrong. For instance I have read my fair share of atomic history and so I was astonished to not find absolutely any mention of William "Deke" Parsons in the book. Parsons was a physicist and naval captain who played a part in designing the 'gun type' Little Boy and was instrumental in arming the Hiroshima bomb on flight. Earlier his hands had almost bled from practicing the arming, which had to occur at a precise given time twenty five thousand feet up in the air on the 'Enola Gay'. There is a superb account of him in Stephen Walker's "Shockwave: Countdown to Hiroshima". In response to a comment I made on Amazon, Mr. Pellegrino replied that he did not mention Parsons simply because he has already been part of so many accounts, which to me does not seem a good enough reason for the exclusion. Apart from this omission I also noted Mr. Pellegrino's statement that Stanley Miller and his advisor Harold Urey won a Nobel Prize for their classic experiment pioneering origin of life research. Urey won a Nobel, but for his discovery of deuterium. Miller was nominated for the prize a few times, and in my opinion should have won it.

Alas, the riveting start of the book and the author's accounts have now virtually fallen apart. In two New York Times articles it has been reported that the most egregious error in the book consists of the story of one Joseph Fuoco who was supposed to be on one of the planes. Mr. Fuoco makes several appearances in the book, and I had found myself scratching my head when I read his accounts, having never heard of him before. The New York Times and other resources discovered that Mr. Fuoco never took part in the bombing missions. Instead the relevant man is one Charles Corliss who has not been mentioned in the book. Astonishingly, Mr. Fuoco seems to have completely duped the author as Mr. Pellegrino himself admitted; he submitted several photographs and letters to Mr. Pellegrino as proof of his role in the mission, including a letter of commendation from President Truman. Clearly Mr. Fuoco proved to be a remarkably facile con man.

But sadly, this and many other errors have cast serious doubt on the validity of the book. This is a pity since Mr. Pellegrino is an interesting writer who has written books on diverse topics ranging from Jesus's tomb to Atlantis . As of now the publisher (Henry Holt) has a blurb on the Amazon page saying that further printing and shipping of the book has been halted (which makes me cherish my first printing copy). Even Mr. Pellegrino's PhD. from Victoria University in New Zealand is being questioned. As usual, an otherwise fine author seems to have sullied his name by sloppy writing on an important topic.

Marshall Nirenberg (1927-2010)

In the latest issue of Cell, Edward Scolnick offers a moving and insightful tribute to his former mentor, Marshall Nirenberg. Nirenberg won the Nobel Prize for Medicine along with Har Gobind Khorana and Robert Holley for one of the most important scientific discoveries, the cracking of the genetic code. Scolnick pinpoints the essential nature of the man and his work.

The world of science knows the substance of his work: He opened up the mystery of the genetic code with the poly-U-polyphenylalanine experiment, then with the triplet binding assay with Phil Leder, and finally with the triplet termination assay with Tom Caskey. From UUU to all 64 triplets: the “periodic table” for molecular biology. But how many have read the poly-U paper—I mean, really read it? Marshall’s approach to science comes through, loud and clear. Every possible control is tested. Every method is described so that anyone else can reproduce it. Every piece of data, even imperfect data, is included in the tables and figures. The incorporation of phenylalanine into the product is more than a thousand-fold over background without the poly-U template, and the incorporation of this amino acid is selective for this homopolymer. How many of us would take the care to characterize the actual product to be sure it had the characteristics of polyphenylalanine? Marshall believed deeply in being meticulous and in being certain that one’s data were true, that the results were due to the variables one had manipulated and were not caused by some vagary that had not been thought of or controlled for. He believed that the methods in one’s paper should be so clearly described that any investigator trying to reproduce the results could do so on the very first attempt. Supplementary sections could never be a part of a Nirenberg paper...
Scolnick also ends with an admonition and a wise message that every member of the government should read.

Members of Congress—guardians of taxpayer dollars and decision-makers for NIH funding—often ask themselves whether the funding for science provided to NIH really matters to the health of the nation. We should tell them to think for a moment about the impact of the cracking of the genetic code. If it were not for Marshall Nirenberg’s work, there would be no recombinant DNA technology, which changed life science and medicine. The sequence of the human genome and the era of modern genomics could not have come into being. Protein therapeutics for cancer and autoimmune diseases, drugs for HIV, statins for atherosclerosis, and modern vaccines all ultimately owe their origin to the knowledge of the code. The genetic code is the periodic table for biological science...How can we honor Marshall Nirenberg’s memory? We can remember all the things he stood for: complete truth in science, meticulous attention to detail, passionate love for discovery, thorough training of students, deep values about how science should be carried out. Marshall will never be dead, because what he stood for in science is timeless—bridging generations of scientists, and bridging millennia
How easy is it to forget that the greatest applied scientific breakthroughs and the greatest fundamental discoveries in science have mainly come out of government-funded basic research? Those who forget this will only condemn their own grandchildren to paucity of knowledge and bereave them of that magical horizon of understanding that science reveals. It is up to all of us to ensure that Nirenberg and others live on through a commitment to such basic scientific research.

Book review: The Dale Carnegie of Silicon-29 NMR

Chemical Shifts and Coupling Constants for Silicon-29 (Landolt-Börnstein: Numerical Data and Functional Relationships in Science and Technology - New Series / Condensed Matter)

By Radha Raman Gupta (Contributor), Manfred Dieter Lechner (Contributor), Heinrich Marsmann (Contributor), Bozhana Mikhova (Contributor), Frank Uhlig (Contributor)

If you read this book, you cannot help but be instantly transformed into a silicon-29 NMR lover and specialist, purveyor of a wonderful, deep and satisfying field of inquiry. This book whose publication was a watershed did for silicon-29 NMR what Dale Carnegie's book did for the average shy person and what Ayn Rand did for capitalism. It finally brought silicon-29 NMR lovers out of the shadows of their self-imposed silence into the mainstream community. As for the price, I can say only one thing; this is one of the very very few products, whether in the shoe store, car store or pet store, whose price is completely justified by its quality. It's a clarion call to all silicon-29 NMR specialists who can finally reclaim the dream that the original topaz and mica lovers only dared to contemplate. I am pretty sure that even after several decades it will remain the most referenced and readily available book on the market, and will continue to be a godsend for those hesitant men and women who are uncertain about their future in the silicon-29 NMR field. Three words; buy it now.

Intramolecular hydrogen bonds in medicinal chemistry

ResearchBlogging.orgIn the latest issue of J. Med. Chem., researchers from Roche in Basel have a nice analysis of intramolecular hydrogen bonds in druglike molecules. An internal hydrogen bond can intuitively confer an important property on a drug; it can make the drug more lipophilic by shielding the hydrogen bonding groups from solvent. Thus, intramolecular h-bonding has emerged as a useful strategy in improving membrane permeability.

The authors look at both the CSD and the PDB and do a reasonably exhaustive analysis of HB motifs of all ligands in these two important databases. They find that internal hydrogen bonds in six membered rings are most common, followed by five and then 7 and 8 membered rings. The HBs in five membered rings are around the edge of definitions for hydrogen bond formation; this indicates the difficulty in defining a HB based on strict geometric criteria. The strongest HBs in six membered rings are, not surprisingly, those between NH and C=O groups, followed by NH and sp2 N groups. In fact nitrogen acceptors for HBs seem to be almost as common as carbonyl acceptors. The authors also find that particularly strong HBs exist for donating groups that are part of a resonance substructure such as an amide linkage (resonance assisted hydrogen bonds). Percentages of hydrogen bonded forms for various structural motifs are noted which could be useful in deliberately designing in such HBs.

After looking at various features of these HBs in several ring sizes including length, angle and torsional dependence, the authors also analyze the effects of internal HBs on membrane permeability. For this they synthesize four pairs of eight model compounds in which each pair consists of two compounds, one able to form a HB and the other one unable to (usually where the donor H is replaced with a methyl). They then calculate parameters like PAMPA permeability, logD and clogP which can be indicators of lipophilicity and permeability. They discover that because of the fragment-based rules used in calculating clogP values, computer programs cannot often predict the increase in lipophilicity resulting from internal HBs. This is a valuable finding that could be translated into a correction applied by computer programs calculating clogP.

The authors find that although internal hydrogen bonds do seem to improve logD, the relationship is not completely straightforward. The hydrogen bonding compounds can exist in closed (h-bonded) and open conformations. They find that only if the open form is a relatively low energy conformation can the molecule readily adopt the closed conformation with a hydrogen bond. They indicate how quantum chemical calculations can be useful for qualitatively rationalizing such energy differences; in one case for instance, the open form was too high in energy according to such calculations and therefore the other form was not easily populated. Because of the sharp dependence of equilibrium populations on free energy differences, I would think that the open form should not be more than about 1.8 kcal/mol higher in energy compared to the closed form (when the population of the former would be about 5%).

This overview should be useful in designing specific internal hydrogen bonds for use in drug design programs.

Kuhn, B., Mohr, P., & Stahl, M. (2010). Intramolecular Hydrogen Bonding in Medicinal Chemistry Journal of Medicinal Chemistry DOI: 10.1021/jm100087s

Quo Vadis, natural science?

On Wednesday last week the town where I lived got 20 inches of snow in a twenty-four hour period. I got an unexpected, happy, day off work. Bizarrely, southern regions like DC and Baltimore got much more than northern ones; Baltimore got 40 inches, Philadelphia got about the same. Records were set in both places for the snowiest winters in recent history. People were left wondering and reeling at this capriciousness of the Norse Gods.

So what could be the reason for this sudden onslaught of severe weather? That's akin to asking what could be the reason for cancer suddenly emerging in someone's body or for a particular drug demonstrating a slew of side-effects. The reasons are non-obvious, often non-intuitive, complex, multifactorial and extremely hard to determine. And that is also what one should say if asked to elucidate reasons for a particularly snowy winter.

But human beings don't work that way. Immediately there sprung up a debate about whether global warming could be responsible for the increased snow. Engaging in the common and never-dying fallacy of equating weather with climate, climate change skeptics declared the cold to be a slap in the face of AGW proponents. On the other side, while most climate scientists are pointing out that single weather events have scant connection with global warming, some proponents are also saying that this is actually a good instance of the effects of global warming, that global warming does predict extreme weather events, that all this is simply part of the connected whole. More vapor in the air, El Nino and other events have been suggested as plausible candidates.

Now let's step back a little and think about this from the educated layperson's perspective. Less snow has been commonly predicted to be a consequence of global warming, but now the same explanation is being provided for lots of snow. The layman should be excused for being skeptical about a model that seems to equally explain diametrically opposite events. Of course, as we mentioned before, more or less snow neither "proves" nor "disproves" global warming. But to me this is yet another reminder of why I don't say much about the topic these days; the whole damn thing has gotten so overly politicized that each side feels compelled to say something non-scientific just to make the other side shut up.

However, from a scientific perspective too this issue illustrates the pitfalls that natural science faces in the twenty first century. When I discussed this issue with my father who is an economics professor the other day, he said "Welcome to the social sciences". Social scientists face such problems all the time. What happens when a model becomes so complex that it can explain virtually any observation you throw at it? (To begin with the model also become so complex that you stop truly understanding it; case in point- derivatives on Wall Street). Surely there seems to be a problem with a model that is invoked to explain both more precipitation and absence of precipitation. That would be akin to a molecular model that predicts the same reason for compounds with both high and low potencies against a protein target.

The hallmark of a judicious model is that it is not so spare as to be useless but also not so full of parameters and variables so as to fit almost any data point. A model that seems to explain everything (as sometimes seems to be the case with global warming) is a bad scientific model because in principle it's hard to see how it could be falsified (Popper again). In addition, you should always ask how many data points are enough to build confidence in a model; statisticians have struggled for decades with this sampling problem, and there is no straightforward general answer. Sadly, it's not climate scientists that have first raised such issues through their model-building. That dubious honor belongs to evolutionary biologists.

Evolutionary biology is notorious for advancing adaptationist explanations which can account for almost any observed trait. For instance, polar bears are white because they are supposed to camouflage well into their surroundings, but penguins are black because their skin should absorb enough sunlight to keep them warm. Now why does the first explanation not apply to the second case and vice versa? Well, in case of evolutionary biology the short answer that is given is "trade offs". Depending on the details of the problem (in this case the species, its body requirements, genetic makeup etc.), in the first case the ability to camouflage won out over the need to remain warm, and vice versa for the second one. But beyond a certain point it can be impossible to actually explain such trade offs since so much in evolution is a matter of contingency. And one can conveniently invoke trade-offs (Shazam!) as a magical whitewashing word for almost any trait. That's hardly an actual explanation.

Nevertheless, such ingenious explanations have often been advocated by evolutionary biologists. In a classic article, Stephen Jay Gould and Richard Lewontin shot down this relentless urge to wrap everything into an adaptionist program; their main point was that every trait is not the consequence of adaptation and natural selection and some traits can be simply carried along for the ride with others without possessing any evolutionary benefit. The main merit of the adaptationist explanations is their internal logic. However, internal logic by itself, no matter how tempting, does not make an explanation. In the absence of experimental data, such hypotheses about evolutionary adaptations are just that, good hypotheses waiting to be validated by good data. A professor of mine got so fed up with these ingenious evolutionary explanations for everything from homosexuality to sloths coming down from trees to bury their feces that he wrote a highly readable book about it. Again, it's not that these ideas are bad, but in the absence of causal evidence they can only remain respectable armchair speculation. So how then do we come up with explanations?

Sadly, here's when fields like evolution and climate change run into fundamental roadblocks of the kind faced by social scientists; the sheer complexity of the system thwarts attempts at clean experiments. The big problem with fields like psychology, sociology and economics is that it is often difficult or even impossible to perform controlled experiments. Admittedly the situation here is worse than climate science, since the data itself is variable and represents a moving target (was the state of mind of your experimental subjects the same on Monday as on Tuesday?). Consider the hundreds of pop science books on neuroscience claiming that things like fMRI scans can "explain" emotions like hate and jealousy, and even spiritual and religious experiences. Other problems notwithstanding, how on earth do we not know that at the very least, like the perpetual observed-induced reality in quantum mechanics, we do not influence what we want to observe? But even in the apparently more rigorous discipline of climate science, models are the result of data conducted under less than ideal non-isolated laboratory conditions from thousands of places over dozens of years. Who can guarantee that at least some of this data won't even be contradictory, let alone that all of it would consistently be of the same standard? To be fair to climate scientists, they usually perform stringent checks on the validity of their models but no checks can help duplicate fine differences in experimental conditions spread over thousands of data points over long time frames.

Lest one think that only the "softer" sciences face these problems, witness the current debate about string theory. Skeptics say that about the only reason that the framework is so highly regarded is because it seems to be logically internally consistent, is mathematically elegant and seems to tantalizingly "feel right". All these qualities can be respectable, but I suspect that the pioneers of modern science in the eighteenth and nineteenth century would not have been happy with this state of affairs. From what I have read, there seem to be no hard experimental tests that could provide strong support for string theory.

That then is the dilemma the natural sciences find themselves in in my opinion, a dilemma that the social sciences have faced for centuries. In fact one can argue that the dilemma has been caused by the social sciences finally intersecting with the natural science as their integrated whole has become more and more complex and is now tackling extremely convoluted territory like the brain, the climate, the universe, human behavior, the economy, evolution and the mechanisms of drug action and disease. With this kind of complexity, scientists have been resigned to pick between two quite unsastisfactory choices; either no explanation at all, or an "explanation" based on models, internal logical consistency, "aesthetics" and elegance (case in point- string theory) and ingenious sounding armchair explanations. In many cases the underlying systems are simply so dense that scientists are forced to perform extensive parametrization and model building. There is probably an equation somewhere relating excessive parametrization to risk of model failure.

Nonetheless, in the absence of controlled experiments, there is not much that science can lean on at this point. But in fact one can argue that science actually proceeds in this way, by tentatively accepting hypotheses. As long as it's kept in mind that the hypotheses are only hypotheses, we can still have a wall to grasp as we grope around in the dark. If we start regarding the hypotheses as explanations and facts, we will leave the safety of that frail wall to grasp at imaginary will-o-wisps at our own peril.

An alternative BBC list for the "educated" mind

So there's this little blurb going around on Facebook in which the BBC has listed 100 books written over the last 200 years or so and asked people how many they and their friends have read. The books are diverse and include everything from Jane Austen to J D Salinger to Harry Potter.

Obviously the BBC thinks this list is important in some way or that people who have read some of these books are educated or well-informed. There is a note informing us that most people would have read only 6 out of those 100 books. Perhaps this is startling.

But what is startling by orders of magnitude is that this list of 100 books does not include a single scientific work. Now of course people would not be expected to have read The Principia. But what about Darwin's "The Origin of Species"? Or, looking at something more modern and still pivotal, Thomas Kuhn's "The Structure of Scientific Revolutions"? These volumes are comparable to many of the books listed by the BBC, certainly in terms of comprehension, and also almost certainly in terms of importance.

Most prominently, what about C P Snow's "The Two Cultures" which lamented the rift between science and the humanities? You want to see a classic example of this rift? WItness the BBC list! Snow would have nodded his head vigorously, especially and most ironically because the exclusion of his own volume from the list makes his point resoundingly clear.

So, dear BBC, if I were to draw up my own short and admittedly limited list of scientific works that surely deserve as much of a place in the "educated" man's mind as the august books you present, I would cite the following. I haven't read all of these works; but with all I have a passing familiarity and some I have read more seriously. Let's even forget Newton's "Principia" for now and focus on the last 200 years as the BBC mostly has, and even just on the 20th century. Of course some of the following are more important than others; some are popular treatments while others are defining and fundamental volumes for their respective fields. But one can still come up with a highly readable list, which in my opinion would enrich the mind of any human being.

1. The Origin of Species- Charles Darwin

2. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions- Thomas Kuhn

3. The Logic of Scientific Discovery- Karl Popper

4. Silent Spring- Rachel Carson

5. Science and the Common Understanding- J. Robert Oppenheimer

6. Principia Mathematica- Bertrand Russell and Alfred North Whitehead

7. Physics and Philosophy- Werner Heisenberg

8. Flatland: A Romance of Many Dimensions- Edwin Abbott

9. On Growth and Form- D'Arcy Thompson

10. What is Life?- Erwin Schrodinger

11. Men of Mathematics- E T Bell

12. Microbe Hunters- Paul De Kruif

13. The Mismeasure of Man- Stephen Jay Gould

14. The Selfish Gene- Richard Dawkins

15. Sociobiology- E O Wilson

16. Mr. Tompkins- George Gamow

17. The Double Helix- James Watson

18. The Nature of the Chemical Bond- Linus Pauling

19. Chaos- James Gleick

20. Advice to a Young Scientist- Peter Medawar

and finally

21. The Two Cultures- C P Snow

Consider the diverse and varying importance of these works. Kuhn and Popper are defining volumes in the philosophy of science. Darwin needs no explanation. Schrodinger inspired a generation of physicists like Francis Crick to change fields and initiate a revolution in biology. E O Wilson's book started a fierce chapter in the "nature vs nurture" debate whose ramifications can still be felt. In one fell swoop Gould demolished the foundations of scientific racism and eugenics. Pauling's book is one of the most important scientific works of all time and redefined chemistry. D'Arcy Thompson's beautiful volume established the mathematical foundations of developmental biology. Bell and De Kruif both inspired dozens of famous scientists like Andrew Weil and John Nash who went on to do groundbreaking work and win Fields and Nobel medals. Russell's book was a landmark event designed to provide a foundation for all of mathematics. Watson's book is considered the archetype of how real science is done, warts and all. Carson became the godmother of the modern environmental movement. On a more limited but important level, Gleick, Gamow and Dawkins made chaos theory, quantum physics and selfish genes comprehensible to the layman. And Medawar, Oppenheimer and Snow wrote deeply thoughtful volumes on the relationship between science, society and culture.

Now I suppose it would not be too presumptuous to ask the question; how many of these have the BBC list-makers read?

The writings of John Cassidy

For the last several weeks I have been enjoying John Cassidy's "How Markets Fail". I am almost done with the volume and have to say that it is one of the best and most balanced critiques of markets that I have read. Cassidy who was educated at Oxford and certainly knows his economics carefully documents the history of how academic mathematical theories like Arrow's impossibility theorem and Robert Lucas's theory of rational expectations came to be mistaken as practical rules for application to the free market when they were really supposed to be not much more than ideal mathematical constructs. He also documents very well how most free market theorists did not include the behavioral economic approaches pioneered by psychologists.

Even more enlightening is Cassidy's series of interviews with Chicago school economists like Richard Posner, Gary Becker and Eugene Fama. It is heartening to see how most of these people who were once die hard free marketeers are now taking a more moderate stance towards the world and accepting the limitations of things like rational expectations and the efficient market hypothesis. All except Eugene Fama, who in his interview appears to be as much of a stubborn free market "fundamentalist" as anyone else, the last man manning the fort, keeping a brave face and clinging to the flag known as the efficient market hypothesis, with smoke and mirrors being his main weapon of combat. Behavioral economists who were once despised at Chicago are now part of the establishment there.

Very enlightening and more than a little gratifying. I would strongly suggest especially the interviews and also the book.

Scaling further GPCR summits

ResearchBlogging.orgThere's a nice review on GPCRs and their continuing challenges in the British Journal of Pharmacology this month. The authors focus on both structural and functional challenges in the characterization of this most important class of signaling proteins. As is well-known, drugs targeting GPCRs generate the highest revenue among all drugs. And given their basic roles in signal transduction, GPCRs are also clearly very important from an academic standpoint. Yet there is a wall of obstacles confronting us.

For starters there are the well-known problems with crystallization plaguing all membrane proteins like GPCRs. Until now only four GPCRs- rhodopsin, beta1 and beta2 adrenergic receptors and A2a adenosine receptor- have been crystallized, and the publication of each structure was considered a breakthrough. As the review mentions, the proteins are unstable outside the membrane and conditions for stabilization and crystallization are frequently incompatible; for instance stabilization is often effected by long-chain detergents while the opposite is true for crystallization. To circumvent these problems clever strategies have been adopted and immense trial and error and hard work were required. The rhodopsin and adrenergic receptors were crystallized by point mutations and special techniques; in one case an antibody was tethered to the protein and in another case a fusion protein was attached to stabilize the domain.

It's when we enter the dense jungle of GPCR biology that crystallization problems almost start sounding trivial. GPCRs couple to a variety of ligands including well-known biogenic amines (like adrenaline and serotonin), peptides, proteins and nucleotides. Where is starts to become complex is in the kind of response these ligands elicit, which could be full agonism, partial agonism, inverse agonism and full antagonism.

What structural features distinguish these different responses from each other? This is a key question in GPCR biology. But not only can ligands be agonists or antagonists but they can act in different ways on the same GPCR, activating different pathways. The case of partial agonists is especially interesting and more protein-partial agonist structures would be quite valuable.

The traditional model of protein binding assumes two dominant states, inactive and active. Agonists stabilize the active state, antagonists stabilize both states, and inverse agonists stabilize the inactive state. But, as the authors say, the traditional model is slowly undergoing a revision:

The concept of a receptor existing in a simple pair of active and inactive states (R and R*) is no longer sufficient to explain the observations of pharmacology. Agonists vary considerably in their efficacy and how this relates to the bound conformational states is unclear. A partial agonist with 50% efficacy could fully activate 50% of the receptors or could activate 100% of the receptor by 50%. Alternatively, a partial agonist might stabilize a different form of the receptor to a full agonist state and this different conformation might activate the G protein with a lower efficiency. The study of rhodopsin suggests that activation of the receptor involves the release of key structural constraints within the E/DRY and NPxxY regions. Energy provided by agonist binding must be sufficient to break these constraints and stabilize the new active conformation. In the case of rhodopsin, whether this transition is complete or partial depends on the chemical nature of the ligand (Fritze et al., 2003). The retinal analogue 9-demethyl-retinal is a partial agonist of rhodopsin which only poorly activates G protein in response to light. Spin-labeling studies (Knierim et al., 2008) suggest that in the presence of this ligand, only a small proportion of receptors are in the active conformation equivalent to all-trans-retinal. However, this can also result in a new state that is not formed with the full agonist. Therefore, rhodopsin studies suggest that that partial agonism may result in either a reduced number of fully active receptors or conformations which are not capable of fully engaging the signal transduction process. Structures of other GPCRs in complex with partial agonists are required to determine their effects on conformation.
An example makes the hideous complexity clear. The mu-opioid receptor is activated by several ligands including morphine, etorphine and fentanyl. However, morphine acts only as a partial agonist in effecting a phosphorylation endpoint whereas the other two act as full agonists. But it gets more interesting. While morphine effects phosphorylation of the kinase ERK through activation of PKC (protein kinase C), etorphine also activates ERK but by activation of beta-arrestin. Thus the same endpoint can be effected through different pathways. And it doesn't even stop there. Morphine causes the phosphorylated ERK to stay in the cytoplasm while etorphine causes the ERK to translocate to the nucleus. Not done yet; in addition, morphine can reverse its role and act as a full agonist on the adenylyl cyclase pathway.

Thus, the same ligand adopts different roles when activating different pathways. To begin with it's not even clear which pathway is activated under what circumstances. And the problem is only accentuated by the participation of different G proteins in inducing different responses.

Another dense layer of complexity is added by the fact that GPCRs have been found to dimerize and oligomerize. Crystallography can often be misleading in studying these dimers since there are several documented reports of dimers being formed as misleading artifacts of the crystallization conditions.

Apart from the stated problems, there are even more differences in further downstream signaling and receptor internalization induced by oligomerization. It's clearly a jungle out there. No wonder the design of drugs targeting GPCRs needs a measure of faith. For instance consider the various drugs targeting CNS proteins. CNS drug discovery has long been considered a black box for a good reason. Once a drug enters the brain, one can imagine it not only targeting a diverse subset of GPCRs (and even other classes of proteins) but, given the above complexities, also acting separately as agonist and antagonist at the various receptors. We clearly have a long way to go before we can prospectively design a CNS drug that will do all this on cue.

It would be a tall order trying to explain all these differences simply through structural modifications induced by the ligands. Yet whatever signal is eventually transmitted to the G proteins must begin with a crucial structural movement. It seems that elucidating the differences in helix and loop movements induced by partial and full agonists, inverse agonists and antagonists is a tantalizing part of the GPCR puzzle.

Since crystal structure data on GPCR is lacking, modeling approaches especially based on homology modeling have proved especially fruitful. Earlier attempts were all based on the single rhodopsin template. Since then the higher resolution adrenergic and adenosine receptor structures have provided significant insight. But here again numerous caveats abound. Modeling the helices is relatively easy since all GPCRs share the same general 7TM helix topology which is highly conserved, but modeling the fine differences between helices that lead to structural changes upon ligand binding is harder. And most difficult and important of all is modeling the extracellular loops which actually bind the ligands. Subtle changes in loop movement, salt-bridge breakage, hydrophobic effects and interaction of loops with helices is difficult to model. Often a change in conformation of a single residue can be enough to throw the modeling off balance. Nonetheless, the paucity of structural data means that modeling when done right will continue to be valuable. In the absence of structural data, computational ligand-based approaches which search for ligands similar to known compounds could be useful.

We have made a lot of progress in understanding the structure and function of these key proteins. But investigations seem to have unearthed more questions than answers. Which is always good for science since then it can have more choice fodder for contemplation.

Congreve, M., & Marshall, F. (2009). The impact of GPCR structures on pharmacology and structure-based drug design British Journal of Pharmacology DOI: 10.1111/j.1476-5381.2009.00476.x

Zheng, H., Loh, H., & Law, P. (2010). Agonist-selective signaling of G protein-coupled receptor: Mechanisms and implications IUBMB Life DOI: 10.1002/iub.293