Field of Science

Linkland

1. A crystal structure of the important PI3 kinase delta form which may provide insight into designing selective inhibitors of this key kinase implicated in cancer.

2. The discovery that a class of sandalwood odorants targets both the traditional GPCR odorant receptors but also the unexpected estrogen receptor (ER). The targeting of these two apparently functionally unrelated proteins may suggest roles for ORs different from olfaction.

3. And speaking of smell, the identification of odorant receptors in malaria-causing mosquitoes. The researchers identify receptors responding to specific body odors that could help the insects home in. Maybe they can also identify dietary components that cause/eliminate these?

4. And finally, the world's first 1GHz NMR in France. Pacemakers beware.

Indian village has unusually low rates of Alzheimer's disease

This caught my attention recently.
As the sun breaks through the morning mist in Ballabgarh, the elders of the village make their way to their regular meeting spot to exchange stories and share a traditional hookah pipe.

These men are in their sixties and seventies, while their faces bear the evidence of years of hard work in the fields, their minds are still sharp.

In other parts of the world, people of their age would be at some risk of developing dementia. But here, Alzheimer's disease is rare. In fact, scientists believe recorded rates of the condition in this small community are lower than anywhere else in the world.
Apparently the villagers here, mostly farmers, were tested for the ApoE4 gene which has been indicated as a risk factor for Alzheimer's. ApoE4 frequency was the same as in a population of farmers in rural Pennsylvania. Unfortunately the explanations suggested (vegetarian diet, lack of obesity, low cholesterol levels, physically fit farmers) does not seem to be unique to this farming community.
In contrast with lives in Pennsylvania and other parts of the world, the people of Ballabgarh are unusually healthy. It is a farming community, so most of them are very physically active and most eat a low-fat, vegetarian diet. Obesity is virtually unheard of.

Life in this fertile farming community is also low in stress, and family support is still strong, unlike in other, more urban parts of India.

"It all leads to a happy body, and a happy mind and hopefully a happy brain," says Dr Chandra. "Cholesterol levels here are much lower. We believe that is what is protecting the community."
There must surely be other farming communities in India and other places whose residents have a "happy body and a happy brain". I need to look up the original reference.

Simulations long enough to...put you to sleep

ResearchBlogging.orgFor something as widely used for as long as general anesthetics (GAs), one would think that their molecular mechanism of action would have been fairly understood. Far from it.

From Linus Pauling's theory of gases like xenon acting at high concentrations by forming clathrates to more recent theories of GA action on lipids and now on proteins, tantalizing clues have emerged, but speculation remains rife.

In a recent Acc. Chem. Res. review, a group of researchers explains some recent studies on GA action. Now there's a field that to me seems primed for computational studies. This is for two reasons.

Firstly, experimental information on GAs is hard to come by. Consider their chemical features; halogenated, apolar small molecules lacking polar hydrogen bonding and other interactions, binding to their targets with low affinity (it's interesting that halogenation seems to be a key criterion for GA action). In addition most GAs do not bind to a highly specific active site but instead influence protein action indirectly. Such features make any kind of NMR or x-ray structure determination an enormous challenge.

Secondly, molecular dynamics simulations (MDS) have come of age. With recent programs augmented by tremendous gains in hardware and software, microsecond to millisecond simulations have gradually become a reality. This particular field seems to provide a classic and worthy challenge for MDS, since GAs seem to interact indirectly and subtly with proteins by influencing their local and global dynamics rather than binding to well-defined active pockets. Such dynamic perturbations would fail to be captured during the pico to nanosecond timescales typically sampled by MDS. For instance, the most prevalent belief for GAs right now is that they interact with ligand-gated ion channels like the GABA and NMDA receptor and with potassium ion channels. One hypothesis for the mode of action of halothane is that it binds to the open conformation of a potassium ion channel. The channel stays open for milliseconds, thus thwarting experimental study. However, a millisecond transition provides a robust and respectable challenge for long time-scale MD simulations.

At the same time, caveats abound in the field. For instance it's easy to infer that a GA molecule binds to a certain site and obstructs the motion of a tyrosine residue, thus providing support to fluorescence quenching and other studies. But the results of such studies as well as the all-important site-directed mutagenesis studies are notoriously hard to interpret; indirect influences on protein motion may be construed as direct binding to particular sites. Plus, it seems to me that one can read too much into the mere, rather obvious observation that a molecule binding to a protein site inhibits the motion of some residues; whether that observation translates into a realistic phenomenon may be much harder to glean.

So yes, it seems that GA action provides a fertile field for computer simulation. Long MD simulations generally seem to me to be a solution looking for problems; after all most interesting molecular interactions in the body take place on the order of micro to milliseconds. There is a huge number of important problems waiting to be tackled with such tools. However, interpretations of the results will always have to be guided by the sure hand of experiment, with the always important caveat that when it comes to interpretation, one computational study and one experiment can have several offspring.

Vemparala, S., Domene, C., & Klein, M. (2010). Computational Studies on the Interactions of Inhalational Anesthetics with Proteins Accounts of Chemical Research, 43 (1), 103-110 DOI: 10.1021/ar900149j

When radiation misfires...literally

The New York Times has a rather chilling account of how radiation overdose in the treatment of some cancer patients caused deadly side effects leading to death. The entire sobering article deserves to be read. In one case a man's tongue was going to be selectively irradiated; instead his whole face received a blast of radiation that led to a horrible, slow death. Scott Jerome-Parks's story makes for very painful reading. In another case, misguided radiation beams literally cut out a hole in a woman's chest that gradually killed her. This was Alexandra Jn-Charles. Both Mr. Jerome Parks and Ms. Jn Charles died within a month of each other in 2007.

And all this mainly because of computer errors that were not detected by human beings, errors that caused the radiation to be overdosed or misdirected. Seems like one of those classic "technology is a double-edged sword" kind of scenarios with the whole system just becoming too complex for human understanding. In one instance, a wedge in a linear accelerator delivering the radiation was supposed to focus the beam in the "in" position. But the computer that used Varian software- the same software that I used in grad school for operating the NMR spectrometer built by the same company- made a mistake and instead pivoted the wedge to the "out" position, removing the radiation shielding. The mistake was not detected 27 times, leading to acute radiation overdoses in the wrong parts of the body. In the case of the man whose tongue was supposed to be treated, an error in the software failed to save the critical settings for the accelerator which would have focused the radiation to the right parts. The computer repeatedly crashed, leading to the collimator beams being left wide open, and nobody noticed this.

The statistics unearthed by the Times are startling. From 2001 to 2009, more than 600 cases of improper radiation treatment were reported. Out of those, 255 were related to an overdose, while 284 were related to the wrong parts of the body being exposed to radiation. Even in its idealized form radiation has side-effects, so one would assume that doctors and technicians would be deathly serious about operating these protocols. These statistics were collected for New York State, which is apparently supposed to have some of the strictest radiation standards in the country.

What is even more shocking is the lack of transparency due to "privacy laws". Names of the culprits have been withheld, and some of them seem to have been let off the hook with a simple reprimand. St. Vincent's hospital and University Hospital of Brooklyn, where the two accidents had happened, were simply fined a thousand dollars by the city of New York. Some doctors who have participated in the treatments refused to talk to the journalists. There also does not seem to be a single agency responsible for these radiation safeguards. On top of it all there seem to be scant ways for patients to pick beforehand which hospital they would like to receive radiation treatment in, since records of mistakes are not available to the public. The whole shebang sounds appalling.

Now I understand that 600 cases in 8 years is probably small potatoes compared to the total number of cases in which radiation has worked successfully. Nonetheless, the factors responsible for the lapses and the horrendous consequences deserve scrutiny (seriously, death due to "computer error" sounds like something out of a bad science fiction horror movie). For something as serious as radiation treatment for cancer, one would assume that the same kinds of safeguards, fail-safe mechanisms and backup checks would be in place as are used in nuclear reactor safety. What boggles my mind is that there exist no fail safe mechanisms which would simply shut down the system when they detect an overdose. It simply seems that shoddy training, computer error, and lack of accountability are dealing out death and enormous physical and psychological suffering to patients and their families.

Go, learn some linear algebra

When I was taking math classes in college I enjoyed topology, differential equations, calculus and combinatorial math, but somehow could not bring myself to drum up enthusiasm for linear algebra.

If I had picked physics as my major (which I almost did), I would not probably have escaped from the clutches of linear algebra while learning quantum mechanics. As it happened I picked chemistry, and most of the quantum chemistry that was served to me after that was sans linear algebra.

On his blog luysii has an excellent set of notes on linear algebra from a QM class that he audited. As I mentioned on his blog, it's interesting how much one can get away with in QC without linear algebra. Thus, take a look at some classic textbooks- Levine, McQuarrie and the classic Pauling and Wilson- and one can go a long way with very little LA. The only things that you are really required to know are eigenvalues and eigenfunctions, but even then the Dirac notation is usually skipped in elementary QC. About the only QC book I know which utilizes large doses of LA is the sophisticated book by Szabo and Ostlund.

Yet LA matters and as luysii demonstrates, there is a generality and elegance to it. There is at least one key LA theorem which is mandatory knowledge in QC. When you are learning about the variational principle (which is used to find approximations to the ground state energy of a system), you derive the so-called secular equation by utilizing a very important LA theorem; that a set of linear homogeneous equations has a non-trivial (non-zero) solution if and only if the determinant of the coefficients is zero. Further on, matrices also come into play in important ways when you are learning about the calculation of transition states, normal modes, and energy minima in molecular mechanics. In the latter exercise you have to calculate the Hessian matrix and then diagonalize this monstrosity (thank god for computer programs).

Perhaps it's not surprising that QC can go a long way without much linear algebra. QC is an application of QM to problems of chemical interest, and the whole reason why the Schrodinger formulation of quantum theory became hugely more popular than the equivalent Heisenberg matrix formulation was that it was more tractable to applications (essentially plug in the correct expression for the potential energy) and couched in the more familiar 19th century language of differential equations. If you wish to know about matrix mechanics take a look at Max Born's excellent book "Atomic Physics"; I had to give up on that particular section.

But even the great Erwin's celebrated paper introducing his equation was titled "Quantization as an Eigenvalue Problem". Maybe it is worth even for a "quantum engineer" (as the late Wolfgang Pauli once somewhat derisively called Enrico Fermi) to learn some linear algebra.

How much chemistry can we wring out of the universe?

Chemiotics II (luysii) had a very interesting post on his blog about the number of proteins of a given length that can be constructed from the entire mass of the earth. Comparing the masses of amino acids to the mass of the earth, he demonstrated that all the earth's mass will be pretty much exhausted with all combinations of a protein that's only 41 amino acids long, which is peanuts as far as your typical protein goes. Such calculations have great relevance for the origin of life if we are to understand the design and evolution of biomolecules.

One can ask similar questions about crystals or small organic molecules. For the latter one can similarly show that the number is much more than the number of atoms in the universe. But most naturally occurring organic molecules have a preponderance of certain fragments like benzene rings. Similarly, there are only a certain rather small number of symmetry groups for crystals. Therefore it seems that in reality, we are dealing with modular units which are much smaller in number (although still quite large) rather than the bare individual units which compose proteins/small molecules/crystals. Thus once these modular units evolved, natural selection probably worked on them instead of trying out possible combinations of their individual atoms. Also remember that natural selection can work on a population of individuals- any kind of individuals- if one of them shows even the slightest advantage with respect to replication. In case of sequences of amino acids, such replicative advantages could arise from several features; stability, charge distributions that could serve to protect the sequences from aqueous hydrolysis or attract one sequence to another, or conformational flexibility that could serve to effect flexibility in the functions of the sequence. Any one of these features could serve to "fix" a particular sequence or group of sequences in a pool of sequences.

In case of proteins for instance, one should ponder how many of the many possible sequences considered could be energetically favored. Some sequences that pit bulky or similarly charged amino acids next to each other could be disfavored by steric and electrostatic factors. Also in case of proteins, the conservation of 3D structure relative to sequence must have been a boon for natural selection. For instance, there's an enormous number of sequences that can fold up into alpha helices (although certain amino acids are favored and others are disfavored) or sheets (where amino acid preferences are not as pronounced). Thus one gets the feeling that natural selection could have some flexibility in designing sequences that would fold into energetically favored secondary structural motifs. However this would not work as well for the active sites of enzymes, where very specific amino acids need to be located in very specific positions in order to effect catalysis. But even here, certain amino acids such as histidine and lysine are interchangeable in terms of their acid-base catalysis roles.

A particularly interesting case that comes to my mind is that of amyloid. Once thought to be the province of only proteins like ß-amyloid, it has now been extensively shown (most notably by Christopher Dobson of Cambridge University, for instance see Nature Chemical Biology 5, 15 - 22 2009, doi:10.1038/nchembio.131 ) that virtually any protein can form amyloid under the right conditions. Amyloid may have been evolution's dream, since it could have tremendous flexibility in picking sequences and coercing them to form amyloid-like structures under the right conditions. As work in which I participated demonstrated (Biochemistry, 2008, 47 (38), pp 10018–10026, DOI: 10.1021/bi801081c), the simplest of changes in conditions like temperature and pH are enough to drastically modulate the architecture of amyloid assemblies.

Thus, while there was potentially an infinite pool of possibilities to design proteins from, as evolution proceeded, I think that the funnel of possibilities became narrower and narrower as the units needed to achieve optimum design became more tailored and building-block like. It's a very interesting question to contemplate the details of this matter.

A biochemical parody of Bryan Adams

For some reason when I was in high school Bryan Adams was big, and we used to listen to his songs all the time. These days I find many of his songs too sappy, but I still love some of the melodies and find myself going nostalgically down memory lane when "Summer of '69" or "Everything I Do" or "Cloud Number Nine" wafts on to the air from somewhere.

So yesterday I happened to be looking at a particularly ravishing picture of dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) and Adams's "Have You Ever Really Loved A Woman" randomly started playing on my iPod and Bam! The two topics meshed together in an ungodly union. So here is my tribute to Bryan Adams with profound apologies...an ode to that perfect protein which we can only covet. The original version is copied first to mitigate the trauma that will follow.

HAVE YOU EVER REALLY LOVED A WOMAN

To really love a woman
To understand her - you gotta know it deep inside
Hear every thought - see every dream
N' give her wings - when she wants to fly
Then when you find yourself lyin' helpless in her arms
You know you really love a woman

When you love a woman you tell her
that she's really wanted
When you love a woman you tell her
that she's the one
she needs somebody to tell her
that it's gonna last forever
So tell me have you ever really
- really really ever loved a woman?

To really love a woman
Let her hold you -
til ya know how she needs to be touched
You've gotta breathe her - really taste her
Til you can feel her in your blood
N' when you can see your unborn children in her eyes
You know you really love a woman

When you love a woman
you tell her that she's really wanted
When you love a woman
you tell her that she's the one
she needs somebody to tell her
that you'll always be together
So tell me have you ever really -
really really ever loved a woman?

You got to give her some faith - hold her tight
A little tenderness - gotta treat her right
She will be there for you, takin' good care of you
Ya really gotta love your woman...

Then when you find yourself lyin' helpless in her arms
You know you really love a woman
When you love a woman you tell her
that she's really wanted
When you love a woman
you tell her that she's the one
she needs somebody to tell her
that it's gonna last forever
So tell me have you ever really
- really really ever loved a woman?

Just tell me have you ever really,
really, really, ever loved a woman? You got to tell me
Just tell me have you ever really,
really, really, ever loved a woman?


HAVE YOU EVER REALLY LOVED A PROTEIN

To really love a protein
To understand her - you gotta know her deep inside
Hear every helix - see every sheet
N' give her energy - when she wants to jiggle
Then when you find yourself staring helpless at her domains
You know you really love a protein

When you love a protein you tell her
that she's really conformationally correct
When you love a protein you tell her
that she's catalytically perfect
she needs somebody to tell her
that her half-life?s gonna last forever
So tell me have you ever really
- really really ever loved a protein?

To really love a protein
Let her hold your high-affinity binders-
til ya know how she needs to be crystallized
You've gotta mass spec her - really sequence her
Til you can feel her atoms in your spectrometer
N' when you can see the unformed hydrogen bonds in her pockets
You know you really love a protein

When you love a protein
you tell her that she's really evolutionarily conserved
When you love a protein you tell her that she's peptidase-digestion preserved
she needs somebody to tell her
that her fold will always hold together
So tell me have you ever really -
really really ever loved a protein?

You got to give her some metal ions - hold her co-factors
A little pH-control - gotta treat her ionization state right
She will be there for you, takin' good care of your ligands
Ya really gotta love your protein...

Then when you find yourself staring helpless at her PDB coordinates
You know you really love a protein
When you love a protein you tell her
that she's really conformationally correct
When you love a protein you tell her
that she's catalytically perfect
she needs somebody to tell her
that her half-life?s gonna last forever
So tell me have you ever really
- really really ever loved a protein?

Just tell me have you ever really,
really, really, ever loved a protein? You got to tell me
Just tell me have you ever really,
really, really, ever loved (that helical, sheety, hydrogen bondalacious) protein?

Almost back

I have been in Tasmania for the last three weeks visiting family, enjoying sunny weather while my home in the northeast faced the wrath of the Norse gods. Back next week for a new year of chemical bloggity bloggings.

Happy New Year

The price of global warming science is eternal vigilance

John Tierney of the NYT weighs in on the hacked emails and accurately nails it
I’ve long thought that the biggest danger in climate research is the temptation for scientists to lose their skepticism and go along with the “consensus” about global warming. That’s partly because it’s easy for everyone to get caught up in “informational cascades”, and partly because there are so many psychic and financial rewards rewards for working on a problem that seems to be a crisis. We all like to think that our work is vitally useful in solving a major social problem — and the more major the problem seems, the more money society is liable to spend on it.

I’m not trying to suggest that climate change isn’t a real threat, or that scientists are deliberately hyping it. But when they look at evidence of the threat, they may be subject to the confirmation bias — seeing trends that accord with their preconceptions and desires. Given the huge stakes in this debate — the trillions of dollars that might be spent to reduce greenhouse emissions — it’s important to keep taking skeptical looks at the data. How open do you think climate scientists are to skeptical views, and to letting outsiders double-check their data and calculations?
We are all subject to the confirmation bias, and I can say from experience that we have to battle it in our research every single day as fallible human beings. But as Tierney says, when the stakes are so incredibly high, when governments and international budgets and debts and the fate of billions is going to be affected by what you say, you better fight the conformation bias ten times as much as usual.

Listen to Capt. Ramsey, son:
"Mr. Hunter, we have rules that are not open to interpretation, personal intuition, gut feelings, hairs on the back of your neck, little devils or angels sitting on your shoulders..."

The damning global warming emails; when science becomes the casualty

By now everyone and his grandmother must have heard about the hacked emails of the prestigious University of East Anglia Climate Research Unit (CRU). The emails were sent by leading climate change scientists to each other and seem to express doubts and uncertainty. More importantly they also seem to display some troubling signs of rather dishonest discourse, with scientists trying to hold dangerously unfavorable opinions of journal editors who seem to be open to publishing papers that don't seem to agree with their views, and asking each other to delete emails which might signal doubt.

There is at least one example of bad science revealed in the emails. It seems that one set of data from tree ring proxies did not show the expected rise in temperatures for a particular period and showed a decline. What was done was that just for that period, a different set of data from another method which did show the rise was grafted on to this piece of data. John Tierney of the NYT has the two graphs on his blog. Does this change the general conclusion? Probably not. Is this bad science and enough to justify a flurry of indignant questions in the minds of outsiders? Certainly so. Good science would have meant revealing all the pieces of data including those which showed a decline.

Now what is remarkable (or perhaps not remarkable at all) is the vociferous political- not scientific- reaction that has erupted in blogs all over the internet. I would point readers to my fellow blogger Derek Lowe's succinct summary of the matter. While I am not as skeptical about climate change as he is, it is disconcerting to see how much political, personal and social baggage the whole issue is carrying. Whenever a scientific issue starts carrying so much non-scientific baggage, one can be assured that we are in trouble.

The comments on most blogs range across the spectrum. There are the outright deniers who claim that the emails "disprove global warming"; they don't, and I can't see how any set of personal exchanges could say almost anything definitive about a system as complex as the climate. Phrases like "hide the decline" (in the case of the above tree ring proxy data) and "trick" have been taken out of their technical context to indicate subversion and deception. And then there are the proponents who want to act like nothing has happened. I like George Monbiot's take on it where he says that even if the science of climate change has certainly not come crashing down, the public image of climate change has been dealt a serious blow, and denying this would simply mean burying your head in the sand. After all, we are supposed to be the good guys, the ones who are supposed to honestly admit to our limitations and failings, and we are not doing this. What ramifications this will have for the important Copenhagen climate summit this month is uncertain.

However, the very fact that we have to worry as much about the public image of climate science as the science itself plainly speaks to the degree of politicization of the issue. I think the liability of this entire matter has basically become infinite and I think scientists working in the field are facing an unprecedented dilemma which few scientists have ever faced. Here's the problem; we are dealing with an extremely complex system and it is hardly surprising if the science of this system (which after all is only a hundred years or so old) keeps getting revised, reshuffled and reiterated even if the basics remain intact. That would be perfectly normal for a vast, multidisciplinary field like this. That is the way science works. One finds such revision and vigorous debate even in highly specific and recondite areas like the choice of atomic partial charges in the calculation of intermolecular energies. The climate is orders of magnitude more complicated. If the usual rules of scientific discourse were to be followed, making such debates and disagreements open would not be a problem.

But with an issue that is so exquisitely fraught with political and economic liabilities and where the stakes are so enormously high, I believe that the normal process of scientific debate, discourse and progress has broken down and is being bypassed. Scientists who would otherwise engage in lively debate and disagreements have become extremely loathe to make their doubts public. These scientists fear that they would essentially be condemned by both sides. The right wing extremists would seize upon any honest disclosure of debate as the kick that brings the entire edifice crumbling down. They would predictably try to discredit even reasonable conclusions drawn by climate change scientists. At the same time, left wing extremists would essentially disown such scientists and either declare them an anomaly or more predictably declare them to be political and corporate shills. A scientist who honestly voices his doubts would become a man without a country.

This is of course in addition to the ample scorn that establishment upholders like climate blogger Joe Romm would heap on them. Thus, if you are a scientist working in climate change today, it would be rather difficult for you to make even the normal process of science transparent. Plus, most scientists are genuinely scared that all the momentum they have built over the years would fizzle out if their right wing opponents pounce on their private doubts. Think about it. The Copenhagen summit is going to be held in a month. Scientists have faced enormous obstacles in convincing the public and governments about climate change. Your work has been crowned by grudging acknowledgement even by George W Bush and the Nobel Peace Prize for Al Gore. Would you be ready to throw away all this rightly hard-earned and hard-fought consensus for the sake of a few dissenting opinions? The simple laws of human nature dictate that you probably would not.

In my opinion, that is what seems to have happened with the scientists at the CRU. They have been so afraid of not only expressing their doubts (many of which as noted above would be valid given the science involved) but also entertaining other dissenting opinions that they have unfortunately picked the option of trying to silence open debate in a way that would be unacceptable in science in general. One can understand their motivation, but their actions still seem deplorable.

I think these emails point to a much more serious structural problem in the scientific enterprise of climate change. For good reasons and bad, whether to stand up to political hacks or ironically to defend good science, this enterprise has accumulated so much political baggage that it is now virtually impossible for it to compromise, to change, to maneuver even in the face of cogent reasons. The science of climate change has essentially bound itself into a straitjacket. My prediction is that important decisions about this science will in the future be mainly politically motivated. Public consensus not completely backed by good science will be the driving force for major decisions. The consequences of those decisions, just like the climate, are uncertain. We will have to wait and see.

But as usual, the casualty is ultimately science itself. What was good science and ineffective politics before is becoming effective politics and bad science. Whatever else happens, science never wins when it gets so overtly politicized. And hopefully about this there will be universal consensus.