Hopefully the air will clear soon. Until then Frampton will have to stay in Argentina, and we can only hope that he will be exonerated of these rather bizarre charges.
- Home
- Angry by Choice
- Catalogue of Organisms
- Chinleana
- Doc Madhattan
- Games with Words
- Genomics, Medicine, and Pseudoscience
- History of Geology
- Moss Plants and More
- Pleiotropy
- Plektix
- RRResearch
- Skeptic Wonder
- The Culture of Chemistry
- The Curious Wavefunction
- The Phytophactor
- The View from a Microbiologist
- Variety of Life
Field of Science
-
Overpopulation, Overconsumption, War: the Answer is Equality4 days ago in Pleiotropy
-
Change of address1 year ago in Variety of Life
-
Change of address1 year ago in Catalogue of Organisms
-
-
Earth Day: Pogo and our responsibility1 year ago in Doc Madhattan
-
What I Read 20241 year ago in Angry by Choice
-
I've moved to Substack. Come join me there.1 year ago in Genomics, Medicine, and Pseudoscience
-
-
-
-
Histological Evidence of Trauma in Dicynodont Tusks7 years ago in Chinleana
-
Posted: July 21, 2018 at 03:03PM8 years ago in Field Notes
-
Why doesn't all the GTA get taken up?8 years ago in RRResearch
-
-
Harnessing innate immunity to cure HIV10 years ago in Rule of 6ix
-
-
-
-
-
-
post doc job opportunity on ribosome biochemistry!11 years ago in Protein Evolution and Other Musings
-
Blogging Microbes- Communicating Microbiology to Netizens12 years ago in Memoirs of a Defective Brain
-
Re-Blog: June Was 6th Warmest Globally12 years ago in The View from a Microbiologist
-
-
-
The Lure of the Obscure? Guest Post by Frank Stahl14 years ago in Sex, Genes & Evolution
-
-
Lab Rat Moving House15 years ago in Life of a Lab Rat
-
Goodbye FoS, thanks for all the laughs15 years ago in Disease Prone
-
-
Slideshow of NASA's Stardust-NExT Mission Comet Tempel 1 Flyby15 years ago in The Large Picture Blog
-
in The Biology Files
UNC physics professor held on cocaine smuggling charges
Hopefully the air will clear soon. Until then Frampton will have to stay in Argentina, and we can only hope that he will be exonerated of these rather bizarre charges.
Book review: The Idea Factory: Bell Labs and the Great Age of American Innovation
During its fifty odd years of existence, Bell Labs was the most productive scientific laboratory on the planet. It won seven Nobel Prizes, contributed innumerable practical ideas underlying our modern way of life and, whether by accident or design, also managed to make some spectacular basic scientific discoveries that expanded our understanding of the universe. How did it possibly accomplish all this? In this authoritative and intensely engaging book, Jon Gertner tells us exactly how.Gertner's book about this great American institution excels in three ways. Firstly, it describes in detail the genesis of what was then an unlikely research institution. Until then most communications related work was considered to be squarely within the domain of engineering. Bell Labs arose from a need to improve communications technology pioneered by its parent organization AT&T. But the real stroke of genius was to realize the value that basic scientists - mainly physicists and chemists - could bring to this endeavor along with engineers. This was largely the vision of two men - Frank Jewett and Mervin Kelly. Jewett who was the first president of Bell Labs had the foresight to recruit promising young physicists who were proteges of his friend Robert Millikan, a Nobel Prize winning physicist and president of Caltech. Kelly in turn was Millikan's student and was probably the most important person in the history of the laboratory. It was Kelly who hired the first brilliant breed of physicists and engineers including William Shockley, Walter Brittain, Jim Fisk and Charles Townes and who would set the agenda for future famous discoveries. During World War II Bell gained a reputation for taking on challenging military projects like radar; at the end of the war it handled almost a thousand of these. The war made the benefits of supporting basic science clear. It was Kelly again who realized that the future of innovation lay in electronics. To this end he moved Bell from its initial location in New York City to an expansive wooded field in New Jersey near Murray Hill and recruited even more brilliant physicists, chemists and engineers. This added further fuel to the fire of innovation started in the 1930s, and from then on the laboratory never looked back.
Secondly, Gertner gives a terrific account of the people who populated the buildings in Murray Hill and their discoveries which immortalized the laboratory. Kelly instituted a policy of hiring only the best minds, and it did not matter whether these were drawn from industry, academia or the government. In some cases he would go to great lengths to snare a particularly valuable scientist, offering lucrative financial incentives along with unprecedented freedom to explore ideas. This led to a string of extraordinary discoveries which Gertner describes in rich and accessible detail. One feature of the book that stands out is Gertner's efforts in describing the actual science instead of skimming over it; for instance he pays due attention to the revolution in materials chemistry that was necessary for designing semiconductor devices. The sheer number of important things Bell scientists discovered or invented beggars belief; even a limited but diverse sampling includes the first transatlantic cable, transistors, UNIX, C++, photovoltaic cells, error-corrected communication, charged-coupled devices and statistical process control that now forms the basis of the six-sigma movement. The scientists were a fascinating, diverse lot and Gertner brings a novelist's eye in describing them. There was Bill Shockley, the undoubtedly brilliant, troubled, irascible physicist whose sin of competing against his subordinates led to his alienation at the lab. Gertner provides a fast-paced account of those heady days in 1947 when John Bardeen, Brittain and Shockley invented the transistor, the truly world-changing invention that is Bell Labs's greatest claim to fame. Then there was Claude Shannon, the quiet, eccentric genius who rode his unicycle around the halls and invented information theory which essentially underlies the entire modern digital world. Described also are Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson, whose work with an antenna that was part of the first communications satellite - also built by Bell - led to momentous evidence supporting the Big Bang. The influence of the laboratory was so formative that even the people who left Bell Labs later went on to greatness; several of these such as John Bardeen and future energy secretary Steven Chu joined elite academic institutions and won Nobel Prizes. It's quite clear that the cast of characters that passed through the institution will probably never again be concentrated in one place.
But perhaps the most valuable part of the book deals not with the great scientific personalities or their discoveries but with the reasons that made Bell tick. When Kelly moved the lab to Murray Hill, he designed its physical space in ways that would have deep repercussions for productive thought and invention. Most crucially, he interspersed the basic and applied scientists together without any separation. That way even the purest of mathematicians was forced to interact with and learn from the most hands-on engineer. This led to an exceptional cross-fertilization of ideas, an early precursor of what we call multidisciplinary research. Labs and offices were divided by soundproof steel partitions that could be moved to expand and rearrange working spaces. The labs were all lined along a very long, seven-hundred foot corridor where everybody worked with their doors open. This physical layout ensured that when a scientist or engineer walked to the cafeteria, he or she would "pick up ideas like a magnet picks up iron filings".
Gertner's highly readable book leaves us with a key message. As America struggles to stay competitive in science and technology, Bell Labs still provides the best example of what productive industrial research can accomplish. There are many lessons that modern organizations can learn from it. One interesting lesson arising from the cohabitation of research and manufacturing under the same roof is that it might not be healthy beyond a point to isolate one from the other, a caveat that bears directly on current offshoring policies. It is important to have people involved in all aspects of R&D talking to each other. But the greatest message of all from the story of this remarkable institution is simple and should not be lost in this era of short-term profits, layoffs and declining investment in fundamental research: the best way to generate ideas still is to hire the best minds, put them all in one place and give them the freedom, time and money to explore, think and innovate. You will be surprised how much long-term benefit you get from that policy. As they say, mighty trees from little acorns grow, and it's imperative to nurture those little seeds.
If you want them to collaborate, you should let them collaborate
The past few months have seen a string of stories about major drug makers shutting down their neuroscience research, a move that seems to be the exact opposite of what they should be doing, even in times of economic distress. Many neurological disorders are the very definition of unmet needs, and one would think that pharma would pump in massive, long-term resources into Alzheimer's disease research with alacrity. But such are the times we live in.But this is exactly what the drug companies should have been doing, putting the basic and clinical scientists under one roof. It's lamentable that they need to have special retreats for bringing these folks together. The reason why this part jumped out at me was because I have just started reading Jon Gertner's great new book about Bell Labs. Many reasons contributed to the institution's phenomenal success, but one notable factor was the concentration of the purest and the most applied scientists under one roof. The firm's pioneering research director Mervin Kelly carefully planned the physical layout of the lab so that everyone, irrespective of specialty or research level, was a stone's throw from everyone else. That way even the purest mathematician was forced to interact and learn from the most hands-on engineer. Research and manufacturing were geographically indistinguishable. There was a very long seven-hundred foot corridor with open offices and labs on each side. It was impossible to walk down the hall and not learn something from someone working in a very different field.
That formula still seems entirely relevant, especially when research has become highly complex and multidisciplinary, and it just seems relatively unproductive to hold special workshops and retreats so that the pure folks can talk to the applied folks. Sure, retreats and workshops can help, but as Bell demonstrated, there's nothing more productive than having the guy who wrote the book on spinal cord injury surgery just down the hall from the guy who wrote the book on dopamine antagonists. Startups and small companies can do this to some extent but they certainly don't have Big Pharma's resources.Image source (Update: As a commentator points out, the photo is not from Bell Labs but from Allied Chemicals. I can imagine the corridor at Bell looking quite similar though).
The unstoppable Moore hits the immovable Eroom
Thanks to Derek I became familiar with an article in the recent issue of Nature Reviews Drug Discovery which addresses that existential question that has been asked by so many plaintive members of the scientific community; why has pharmaceutical productivity declined over the last two decades with no end to this attrition in sight?Gilbert Stork on steaks, synthesis and more
Few chemists in the twentieth century have contributed as many important ideas to the science and art of organic synthesis as Gilbert Stork. Stork has made any number of groundbreaking and elegant contributions to the discipline, from the enamine reaction to radical chemistry to pathbreaking total syntheses like his synthesis of quinine. And from his perch at Columbia University where he has been for almost fifty years, he has emerged as one of his generation's most productive trainers of leading chemists in academia and industry. Here's a nice presentation listing his achievements.“There was this one really idiotic time. I remember I was really scared that I was going to blow up the entire Chemistry Department at the University of Wisconsin. I had a steak on the window ledge of my office. It was the winter, and I used the window ledge as a refrigerator. You obviously were not supposed to be cooking steaks in the lab, but I had a small lab where I was usually alone in there, and so I had a steak. But I also was not aware that biodegradable material is biodegradable, and this steak was clearly degraded on the window ledge. And the question was, what to do with it? And I decided to toss the steak in a hot acid bath which we used to clean up glassware. So, it's fuming nitric and sulfuric acid. It's really aqua regia in that bath, in that heavy lead dish, and the steak.
“And then, as I just had thrown it in there, and it fumed furiously and red fumes of who knows what, nitrous oxide of various kinds were being produced there. I became frantically concerned because fat is glycerides. So, I am hydrolyzing the fat to glycerin. You make nitroglycerine by taking glycerin and nitric acid and sulfuric acid, and obviously, I am going to produce a pile of nitroglycerine and blow up the entire building with my steak.
“Now, what is an interesting point there, why didn't it? And of course, the reason is kinetics. That is, the kinetics of oxidation of the glycerol at that temperature is much, much, much, I mean, infinitely faster than the cold temperature nitration of glycerin. And so the place was safe.”
And second, some reflections on the real value and utility of chemical synthesis:
“The toughest question to ask in synthetic organic chemistry after the work is done is: what have you learned? And you can have extraordinarily complex things. They look complex as hell. Maybe they have 80 asymmetric centers and maybe the answer is, [you've learned] nothing. I mean, you could have learned that humans are capable of enormous focused efforts and are capable of sticking with a problem which is extraordinarily complicated.
On the other hand, if somebody makes polyethylene, as somebody obvi- ously did, then you learn a lot, even though it will not thrill most synthetic chemists because this would be comparable to building a highway for an architect. I mean, it's important, but it's fairly dull compared to [building] the Guggenheim Museum, for instance... ”
“So something could be not terribly glamorous but extremely important, or vice versa. I think that B12 was vice versa. It's enormously complicated.”
That's a really important point he makes, and one that should define the choice of a research problem especially for a young investigator. There's not much point in attempting that 80 step synthesis using "hammer-and-tong" chemistry if it's not going to teach you much; that's also one of the reasons that people like Woodward get so much credit for synthesizing something first, since they really demonstrated that such complex synthesis was possible. On the other hand, throwing in two simple chemicals and watching them form an astonishingly intricate infinite lattice can really teach you something new. So can synthesizing a boringly repetitive polymer with novel properties.
The real deal in chemistry as in any other science is understanding, and the nature of experiments that impart real understanding changes with the evolution of chemical science. Stork's message for new researchers is clear; pick a problem that may not be glamorous, but whose solution would teach you something new. Stamina is not quite as important as creativity and discovery, and although perseverance is admirable, you don't make an important contribution just by proving that you can stick with a problem for ten years. Even though it may appear that way, science is not a marathon; it's scuba diving.
Why it's hard to explain drug discovery to physicists
I minored in physics in college, and ever since then I have had a lively interest in the subject and its history. Although initially trained as an organic chemist, part of the reason I decided to study computational and theoretical chemistry is because of their connections to physics by way of quantum chemistry, electrostatics and statistical thermodynamics. No other science can boast the kind of fundamental insights into the most basic workings of the universe that physics has provided in the twentieth century. Even today when we think of the purest, most exalted science we think of physics.Image source
A new way to look for life on other planets
One of the fundamental properties of light is its polarization which refers to the spatial orientation of the electric and magnetic fields constituting a light wave. There are many fascinating facts about polarized light which are of both academic and applied interest, but perhaps the most intriguing one is the ability of chiral or handed organic compounds to change the plane of polarization of circularly polarized light. This has proven to be an invaluable tool for chemists in detecting and assigning the structures of molecules, especially biological molecules like sugars and amino acids which tend to exist in only form (left or right handed) in nature.1. The authors note that the lunar surface partially depolarizes the light. Wouldn't this happen much more with light coming from very far that has hit multiple potentially depolarizing surfaces? Light could also be depolarized by dense atmospheres or by interstellar media like dust grains and ice grains. More interestingly, the polarization could also be reversed or affected by chiral compounds in outer space.
2. A related question: how intense does the light have to be when it reaches the detectors? Presumably light from worlds that are billions of light years away is going to strongly interact with surfaces and interstellar media and lose most of its intensity.
3. It's clear that chlorophyll is responsible for the signature of vegetation. Alien plants may not necessarily utilize chlorophyll as the light harvesting pigment, in fact they may well be equipped to use alternative wavelengths. There could also be life not dependent on sunlight. How we will be able to interpret signatures arising from other unknown pigments and constituents of life is an open question.
4. It is likely that advanced civilizations have discovered this method of detecting life. Could they be deliberately broadcasting polarized light to signal their presence? In the spirit of a past post, could they do this with specific molecules like amino acids, isotopically labeled molecules or stereoisomers? How sensitive is the polarization to molecular concentration? Any of these compounds would strongly suggest the presence of intelligent life which has developed the technology for the synthesis and purification of organic molecules.
Sterzik, M., Bagnulo, S., & Palle, E. (2012). Biosignatures as revealed by spectropolarimetry of Earthshine Nature, 483 (7387), 64-66 DOI: 10.1038/nature10778
The right questions about modeling in drug discovery
The man who made it possible
There's a nice set of articles in this week's Nature celebrating the birth centenary and work of a man whose work underlies almost all of modern life - Alan Turing. Considering the complete transformation of human life that computing has enabled, Turing's work along with that of his fellow computer pioneer John von Neumann will likely be recognized as one of those watersheds in human history, comparable to the invention of the calculus and the discovery of electricity. It is remarkable to consider how many millions of software engineers and billions of dollars in revenue are being generated every day off these scientists' ideas.The end of biofuels?
Hartmut Michel from the Max Planck Institute of Biophysics has an editorial (open access!) in Angewandte Chemie with a title that makes his views clear: "The Nonsense of Biofuels". He essentially comes down hard on biofuel proponents of all stripes and not just the much hyped ethanol-from-corn lobby. Michel won the Nobel Prize for cracking open the structure of one of earth's most important proteins - the photosynthetic reaction center - so he certainly knows his photosynthesis.